Looking for a cleaner swap for your old conventional lipstick faves? Here are some of my personal favorites that I have successfully swapped out over time. Some of them are almost identical while others are simply the closest I have found yet! Please keep in mind, all colors will look different depending on your natural lip shade and the lighting so it’s best to Google image swatches if you are unsure on the shade. I will continue to add to this as I come across cleaner options and please share any faves you have found as well! All of these options are free of hormone-disrupting plastics, harsh FD&C Lake Dyes, parabens, BHT, fragrance, and more!
CHARLOTTE TILBURY Lipstick
- Amazing Grace- Swap for Lily Lolo Passion Pink
- American Sweetheart- Swap for Nudus 27 Kisses
- Love Liberty- Swap for 100% Pure Wine Cup
- Pillow Talk- Swap for Nudus Halo
MAC Lipstick
- All Fired Up- Swap for Nudus in Zozo
- Blankety- Opal by BAIMS
- Bombshell- Swap for Suntegrity in Sunny Blush
- Brave- Swap for BAIMS in Rose Rock
- Breathing Fire- Swap for 100% Pure in Marrakesh
- Cosmo- Swap for Nudus 27 kisses
- Cream in Your Coffee- Nudus Dreamtime
- D For Danger- Swap for 100% Pure in Aubergine
- Diva- Swap for Trustfund in Play Nice
- Fast Play- Swap for Gabriel in Clay
- Frost- Swap for BAIMS in Pearl
- Girl About Town- Swap for 100% Pure in Sorbetto or Nudus Survivor
- Heroine- Swap for 100% Pure in Tempest
- Honey Love- Swap for Nu Evolution in Allure or 100% Pure in Sandstone
- Impassioned- Swap for Nu Evolution in Delish
- Kinda Sexy- Swap for Saint Cosmetics in Barcelona
- Lady Danger – Swap for Saint Cosmetics in Singapore or Nu Evolution in Femme Fatale
- Marrakesh- Swap for BAIMS in Red Jade
- Mehr- Swap for 100% Pure in Sahara
- Modesty- Swap for Nudus in Naked
- Morange- Swap for Saint Cosmetics in Las Vegas
- Party Parrot- Swap for Nu Evolution in Delish
- Patisserie- Swap for Suntegrity Lip CPR in Sunny Blush
- Persistence- Swap for Noyah in Melted Mocha
- Pink Pigeon- Swap for Noyah in Malbec
- Pink Plaid- Swap for Saint Cosmetics in Dallas
- Please Me- Swap for Noyah Desert Rose, Saint Miami or Lily Lolo Temptation
- Rebel- Swap for Noyah in Current News or Saint Cosmetics Abu Dhabi
- Ruby Woo- Swap for Saint Cosmetics in New York or Nudus in Revenge
- Russian Red- Swap for 100% Pure in Nopal
- Smoked Almond- Swap for 100% Pure in Cacti
- Taupe- Swap for 100% Pure in Mojave
- Twig- Swap for Nudus Dreamtime
- Velvet Teddy- Swap for Nudus 27 Kisses
MAC Lip Liners
- Boldly Bare- Terra Cotta by Zuzu
- Chesnut- Chestnut by Gabriel
- Soar- Innocence by Zuzu
- Spice- Nutmeg by Gabriel
NYX LIP LINERS
BOBBI BROWN Lipgloss
- Lipgloss in Buff- Swap for Crunchi Namaste or Lily Lolo Damson Dusk
- Heather Pink- Swap for Suntegrity Solar Rose
What do you recommend for long staying lipsticks like LipSense?
Thank you so much for doing this! This is awesome and such a help. Ever since I started following your blogging and instagram posts I am so much more excited for makeup. Any suggestions for swaps for taupe and faux from Mac?
Such a helpful, extensive list – thank you! Can you possibly recommend a dupe for the Marc Jacobs sheer lip color in Role Play? It’s by far my favorite lipstick I’ve ever had and I can’t seem to part with it!
This is excellent… I need some pure non-toxic make up for my melanin skin tone though!!! Please help
Do you know of any dupes for Clinique Black Honey??
Could you do more about dupes? I’m just now starting green beauty and would love to know!
what shade are you wearing in this picture?
I really need some help in green beauty makeup dupes for cult makeup
Charlotte tilbury airbrush flawless powder
NARS Radiant creamy concealer (the wand) and pot for cut crease in eye
The balm cosmetics manizer set (the 3 highlighter set)
Mac black track eye gel
Urban decay 24/7 glide on pencil
Lancome artliner in black
Anastasia Beverly hills brow pencil
Urban decay setting spray
MAC Lip Liner Pencil:
1. Soar
2. Whirl
3. Hover
4. Magenta
5. Brick
6. Half Red
7. Cherry
8. Auburn
9. Talking points
Nars Velvet matte lip pencil: (Dupes)
1. Dirty Mind
2. Do me baby
All day Luminous NARS- Syracuse (my color)
Hi, are there any clean dupes for Nars Red Square Matte Lip Crayon? Thx
Yes! This one is pretty darn close https://www.theorganicbunny.com/product/100-pure-semi-matte-lipstick-sonora/
I am enchanted with this article!!! 💚💚
Since I got rid of all my lipsticks I haven’t feel right when I do my makeup I can’t believe I can finally swap all those -> kinda sexy, blankety, twig, velvet teddy, please me, ruby woo and russian red. Just looking for clean products to swap the Nars Orgasm blush lip and orgasm nail polish.
Blush swap easy! https://www.theorganicbunny.com/product/zuii-organic-flora-blush-in-melon/
Hi! The lipstick colour looks fantastic! Which product are you wearing on this picture?
Thanks,
Verena
Hi! 🙂 Do you have any recommendations for a lipstick like MAC “Hue”. It’s a very light pink colour, not super shiny but not matte. Or the eyeshadow “Suspect” by Urban Decay?
I’m desperate to find a clean dupe (doesn’t have to be liquid lipstick; any form will do) of Jeffree Star’s Gemini liquid lipstick. If you come up with anything, please do let me know. Thank you!
Hi! Thank you so much for this amazing list! It has been really helpful 🙂 Any good dupe recommendations for Mac’s Whirl lip liner and Charlotte Tilbury’s Hollywood Highlight Wand?
I’d love to know of clean dupes for the following Mac lipsticks: Jubilee (lustre), Viva Glam II (satin) and Modesty (Cremesheen). I was also hoping for a dupe for the discontinued Viva Glam V but I think that’s a long shot!