AquaTru vs. Berkey Water Filters
When it comes to water filters, I am always researching and comparing all the varying devices out on the market and very rarely do I find one that meets my standards or that is comparable to my current Berkey filter, however, after coming across the AquaTru filter, I found myself curious to learn more about it. The AquaTru is a true reverse osmosis filter so at first, I was skeptical to try it out but I wanted to keep an open mind because I want to always be open to new ideas!
I must start by saying, we will also be getting a full house water filter which means it will actually filter out the entire home’s water so baths, showers, sinks, hose, it will all be filtered. Because we have recently moved though, I wanted to test our water first, to determine the contaminants in our water in order to choose the very best filter for us as your tap water can truly be contaminated with a wide variety of toxins from dangerous pesticides and herbicides to heavy metals and VOCs. For us, step 1 was using this water test kit as it tests for hundreds of potential contaminants in both city or well water. As soon as our results our back I will share! For now, we are relying on these countertop filters but the whole house unit cannot come soon enough.
Another question many of you asked was if filters like Brita are enough and while they are certainly better than no filter, they do not filter out near as much as the below two filters can. You can read a good comparison of the Berkey vs. Brita here.
When it comes to this AquaTru filter, there are things I really, really love about it but then also, things that aren’t as ideal. I actually started out looking for reasons not to like it since I love my Berkey so much, however, the longer I researched this filter and used it, the more it quickly grew on me and now, it might be my fave? Let’s discuss my pros & cons with this new filter and my old trusty Berkey!
AquaTru Pros & Cons- I don’t want to start off with a con but one big one is that it does require power and needs to be plugged in at all times to work but, one major pro is that the AquaTru does have better testing that is certified to NSF standards. So, what do the results say? Well, the results show that Berkey filters out a tiny bit more than the AquaTru unit does for example- AquaTru removes 96.6% of chlorine whereas Berkey removes 99.9%, however, this is where the testing methods become important as we must understand the amount of water being tested as the more water the filter processes, the more the % being filtered out can drop so while it sounds like Berkey is the winner, not yet!
Another con with the AquaTru is that it comes in plastic, however, AquaTru uses Tritan plastic, the same BPA & BPS-free plastic used in best-selling food blenders like Nutri Bullet and Vitamix. Tritan has been tested at universities and independent third-party labs and the results have overwhelmingly demonstrated that it is safe and free of estrogenic and androgenic activity but if you are like me and still concerned you can always transfer the water out into a glass jar for storage.
Another perk of this device being held to NSF standards is that they also do extraction testing to make sure that no dangerous contaminants leak into the water. Based on their IAPMO testing to NSF standards, AquaTru has been certified to not leak any dangerous contaminants into the water which is really comforting to know it has been tested to that degree so while I dislike the use of the plastic, I do feel comfortable using it at this time. Another big perk of this filter is that it removes 82 different toxic contaminants including lead, fluoride, pesticides, chlorine and drugs, yes drugs.
How it Works- Filtering out the water requires a little more work as there are two containers and they both hold much less than my current Berkey. Once the water is filtered, there is a dump tank that all of the bad water goes to and this has to be dumped after each use. You also have to lift and remove the container, fill it up and then lock it back into place versus with my Berkey you just dump and go. The Berkey is much simpler however this filter is easier to set up than the Berkey.
Clean water on left, wastewater on the right you empty.
Size- My current Berkey holds 1.5 gallons whereas this one only holds .75 gallons. This unit is also much bulkier on the counter than the Berkey, however, the Berkey is much taller so it depends which you have the space for.
Taste- The good news is, I really like the taste of this water, it is much smoother than the Berkey water which makes me feel like it filters better even if the testing says otherwise. It just tastes cleaner as it removes everything from the water. Some express concern that removing the “good” minerals is not ideal, however, we must remember we do get much from our diet and it’s very easy to supplement back in, I take the CT-Minerals by Cellcore twice daily as is so for me it’s no biggie as I get all of the good minerals from that and my diet, therefore, I can afford to lose them in my water.
- Price with my discount is $299, normally $449
- Chlorine reduced by 96.6%
- Fluoride reduced by 93.5%
- Lead reduced by 99.1%
- Chromium VI reduced by 97.2%
- Copper reduced by 95.2%
- Chloroform reduced by 95%
- Must change the filter every 600 gallons to ensure proper performance.
- Removes drugs like Ibuprofen and Naproxen up to 95%
- Uses an advanced 4 stage purification system.
- Filters have a shorter lifespan than Berkey but with proven test results.
- Needs electricity.
- Tritan plastic, BPA/BPS-free housing.
- Certified to NSF standards to remove the contaminants claimed.
- The unit notifies you when filters need changing.
- They have a best water you’ve ever tasted guarantee or your money back!
Travel Berkey Pros & Cons- I have had my Berkey filter for years now and overall, I have really been happy with it! It’s a reasonable price, it’s super simple to use, it filters out almost 99.9% of common contaminants and you can travel easily with it considering no power is needed. I really love that it is made from stainless steel instead of plastic and you simply dump water in and it gets to work. While the above unit filters out Fluoride on its own, for Berkey, you do have to add those filters in, additionally, if you want them so that is one slight con.
My main complaint about Berkey, now that I’ve dug on their testing methods is that their filters are not tested at the capacity they say their filters last so while they have great results after 50 gallons, what are the results after the 1,000th gallon? This is also why they cannot ship to certain states. The reality is, the more water the filter processes, the lower the results go and you never really know because there is no notification like the AquaTru has. While the Berkey is easier to use and it’s amazing to travel with, after you have had it for a year or so, it becomes hard to know if your filter is still performing to their promised levels.
How it Works- It’s quite simple after it is set up, you just remove the top lid and add your tap water in! We have a giant craft that we keep near the spout so we simply fill it then dump it in. The Berkey setup is a much bigger pain than the AquaTru but once it is set up the Berkey is a little easier to use daily.
Size- The Berkey is fairly tall, especially if you add the stand, however, it’s pretty small in diameter so it takes up much less space than the above AquaTru. The Berkey is also prettier in my opinion but I am not sure that is a reason, alone, to buy a filter 🙂
Taste- I think the Berkey water tastes great, however, the AquaTru tastes much smoother as they are a Reverse Osmosis filter that removes even the beneficial minerals Berkey leaves. You can very much taste that difference. Berkey water is still really nice, it just is a hair less smooth because the good minerals are still in the water and you can taste that.
- Price is $278.35 with my discount, normally $293
- Chlorine reduced by 99.9%
- Copper reduced by 99.9%%
- Lead reduced by 99.9%
- Chromium VI reduced by 99.9%
- Copper reduced by 99.9%
- Chloroform reduced by 99.9%
- Fluoride reduced by 97%
- Does not need electricity.
- Removes over 200 contaminants all the while leaving beneficial minerals in the water
- Filters 6,000 gallons per filter but the filters have not been tested for efficiency at this level.
- Filters have a lifetime guarantee but again, they have not been lifetime tested.
- Stainless steel housing.
- Holds more water than the AquaTru.
- No way to know when filters need replacing besides the filtering slows down quite a bit.
- Cannot ship to CA due to their lack of testing.
I personally find myself now reaching for my AquaTru water more now that I know the testing standards, however, the Berkey is still so amazing to have for travel, the dog’s water, washing produce etc… I still drink from my Berkey too so you really cannot go wrong with owning it, but I do think I slightly favor my new filter mostly because of how amazing it tastes! Once you taste it, it really is hard to drink anything else!
So now, how to choose? Well, I think this one is going to come down to priorities and which are most important to you and your family? The good news is, I do have discounts on each unit so whatever appeals more to you, you can save a little money. Have something about these units I missed or forgot? Leave a comment below! I will continue to update this as I find relevant info!